Where two hips meet the ridge, three runs of tile arrive at one point and no tile is made to close it. It gets filled with mortar, and it carries more water than anywhere else on the roof.
Look at the top of a tile roof where a hip runs up and meets the main ridge. Two lines of hip tile and one line of ridge tile all arrive at the same point. On most houses it happens at both ends of the ridge, and on a cut-up roof it happens several times.
There is no tile made for that junction. The three runs each end in an open mouth pointing at the same spot, and the gap between them sits directly over the field tiles below. Whoever built the roof had to close that gap with something, and on almost every roof in the Lower Mainland that something is mortar.
Mortar is rigid. A roof is not. It expands in the sun, contracts overnight, and does that every day for decades. The bond between the mortar and the tile cracks, water gets into the crack, and in a cold snap it freezes and opens the crack wider. Piece by piece the mortar spalls out and washes down the roof.
What is left is an opening straight through to the underlay. And it is at the exact point where three separate runs of roof water converge, so the volume passing over that opening is the highest anywhere on the roof.
It is the most exposed single point on a tile roof, and the one that was closed up with the least durable material on it.

Most roof details leak a trickle. This one delivers the concentrated runoff of three roof planes into a single opening. When we get called to a tile roof leak that nobody else has been able to find, this junction is one of the first places we look.
Two houses on the same street with the same stain on the same ceiling can turn out to be two different problems. What is actually going on only shows up once someone is up there with the tiles off.
Roof Inspection Report, $500. We get on the roof, find what is actually happening and give you written findings with photos. Book the repair with us and the $500 comes off the job.
Intermittent tile roof leaks have a short list of usual suspects, and this is near the top of it.